The Best Bobtail Insurance Agencies of 2026
From May through July 2026, our research team evaluated 50+ bobtail insurance agencies serving commercial trucking operations across the United States. We focused solely on family-owned independent agencies specializing exclusively in trucking. These businesses represent multiple carriers and act as an intermediary between motor carriers and the insurers that underwrite coverage. We pulled data from agency websites, carrier filings, industry publications, and direct outreach to agency representatives. Each agency was scored using a six-factor algorithm:
-
Specialization in trucking insurance (25%): Trucking-only agencies understand bobtail coverage gaps better than generalists.
-
Access to multiple carriers (20%): More carriers means more competing quotes and better terms.
-
Account service and response time (20%): Fast, knowledgeable service matters as much as the policy itself.
-
Quote turnaround speed (15%): A slow quote keeps your truck sitting still and costing you money.
-
State coverage and licensing (10%): The agency must be licensed in every state you operate in.
-
Online reviews and reputation (10%): Reviews signal how an agency treats clients after the sale.
We rank-ordered every agency in our dataset using this algorithm. The table below presents the top six performers, followed by in-depth reviews of each.
The Best Bobtail Insurance Agencies of 2026
1. Truck Writers
Truck Writers has worked exclusively in trucking insurance since 1983, and the Blaine, Minnesota agency is still family-owned and run by the same family more than four decades later. That kind of single-industry focus shows up in the details: the agency’s account teams know the difference between bobtail coverage and non-trucking liability without needing it explained, and they staff every client relationship with a dedicated team rather than rotating you through a call center. Single-unit owner-operators can typically get a quote back the same day they call, which is faster than most full-service agencies in this comparison.
Location: Blaine, MN (additional office in Welcome, MN)
Year Founded: 1983
Services Offered: Auto liability, physical damage, bobtail and non-trucking liability, motor truck cargo, workers’ compensation, freight broker bonds, per-trip excess coverage, captive and self-insurance programs
Summary of Online Reviews: Clients consistently point to a dedicated account team model rather than a rotating call queue.
2. RJS Truck Insurance
RJS Truck Insurance has operated out of Laguna Niguel, California since the early 1990s, and it has built the strongest verified customer service reputation of any agency in this comparison. Google reviews aggregated through Trustindex show a 5.0 rating across 345 reviews, with clients repeatedly mentioning fast responses, bilingual support, and agents who stay reachable for years after the sale. The agency shops a roster of carriers that includes Great West Casualty, Progressive, Great American, Northland, and Wilshire, giving owner-operators real options rather than a single quote.
Location: Laguna Niguel, CA
Year Founded: 1992
Services Offered: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, bobtail, non-trucking liability, general liability, workers’ compensation
Summary of Online Reviews: Clients consistently describe fast response times and agents who remain personally reachable throughout the relationship, with several long-term clients noting they’ve worked with the same agent for a decade or more.
3. Marquee Insurance Group
Marquee Insurance Group, based in Roswell, Georgia, has built the deepest carrier bench of any agency on this list. The agency has appointments across 30-plus A-rated carriers and was named one of ten founding members of Highway’s Certified Insurance Agency network, a designation tied to accuracy and speed on certificates of insurance. For an owner-operator or small fleet that wants an agency capable of shopping a wide range of markets for the best bobtail terms, that breadth is a genuine advantage.
Location: Roswell, GA (additional offices in Athens, GA; Nashville, TN; and Charleston, SC)
Year Founded: 2014
Services Offered: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, freight broker insurance, per-shipment cargo, BOOST safety monitoring program
Summary of Online Reviews: Clients frequently credit specific agents with significant premium savings and responsive service, though a share of reviews describe slow claims handling or paperwork errors that required direct escalation to resolve.
4. Aronson Group
Aronson Group, founded in 2017 in Bettendorf, Iowa, built its business specifically around small fleets running one to nine trucks, and that focus shows in both its technology and its reviews. The agency works with a narrower set of trucking-focused carriers than larger agencies like Marquee or Truck Writers; so for a straightforward small fleet or new-venture operator, that list is rarely a problem. They also hold a 4.9 rating across 55 reviews, and several reviewers specifically mention getting bobtail coverage bound within hours of calling. Founder Thomas Aronson is directly involved in the business, including personally following up on service complaints, which is unusual for an agency at this size.
Location: Bettendorf, IA
Year Founded: 2017
Services Offered: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, bobtail and non-trucking liability, new venture coverage for first-year authorities
Summary of Online Reviews: Clients frequently cite fast turnaround and direct access to the founder when problems come up, including at least one review specifically describing quick same-day bobtail coverage.
5. Joe Morten & Son
Joe Morten & Son has specialized in trucking insurance since 1936, making it the oldest agency in this comparison by a wide margin, and its footprint reflects that history. The South Sioux City, Nebraska agency now serves more than 9,000 customers across 46 states from ten office locations, giving it the broadest multi-state reach on this list. The agency’s ties run deep: it helped establish Great West Casualty Company, one of the country’s best-known trucking carriers, back in 1956.
Location: South Sioux City, NE (10 locations nationwide)
Year Founded: 1936
Services Offered: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, general liability, workers’ compensation, excess liability, owner-operator programs
Summary of Online Reviews: Clients consistently point to long-term advisory relationships rather than one-time transactions.
6. Owner Operator Direct (LuckyTruck)
Owner Operator Direct operates under the LuckyTruck brand today, a Cincinnati-based digital platform founded in 2019 that lets owner-operators get an online quote and bind coverage without picking up the phone. For buyers who know exactly what they need and want to move fast, that self-serve model is the quickest quote-to-bind process in this comparison, and the platform also offers add-ons like a trucking-specific fuel and expense card.
Location: Cincinnati, OH (online platform; licensed in select states)
Year Founded: 2019
Services: Auto liability, physical damage, motor truck cargo, non-trucking liability, occupational accident, trucking-specific fuel card
Summary of Online Reviews: Clients consistently highlight the speed of its online quoting process, though public review volume specific to claims and account service is too limited to draw a confident conclusion.
The Best Bobtail Insurance Agencies by Specialty
We also broke down the top bobtail insurance agencies into three subcategories.
Best for Single-Unit Owner-Operators and Small Fleets (2-9 Trucks)
-
Truck Writers
-
Aronson Group
-
RJS Truck Insurance
-
Marquee Insurance Group
-
Owner Operator Direct (LuckyTruck)
Best for Account Service and Response Time
-
RJS Truck Insurance
-
Truck Writers
-
Aronson Group
-
Joe Morten & Son
-
Marquee Insurance Group
Best for Multi-State and Growing Fleets (10+ Trucks)
-
Marquee Insurance Group
-
Joe Morten & Son
-
Truck Writers
-
RJS Truck Insurance
-
Aronson Group
Conclusion
The best bobtail insurance agency for a given operation depends on fleet size, how often you’re bobtailing, hauling territory, and how much hands-on account support you need. The agencies on this list represent the strongest independent options across that full range, from single-truck owner-operators who want a fast, no-frills quote to growing fleets that need an agency built to scale with them.
Truck Writers ranked first because of what it combines: 43 years of exclusive trucking focus, a dedicated account team for every client, true multi-carrier independence that keeps pricing competitive, and a product depth, including captive and self-insurance programs and freight broker bonds, that few other agencies on this list can match. Every carrier relationship, every coverage recommendation, and every account service decision is built around the specific demands of trucking, not adapted from a general commercial lines playbook.
